Monks and Snow Lions and Chinese Tourists…Oh My!

Sitting here in an Internet cafe in Lhasa, I’m enjoying a few moments of refuge from the throngs of Chinese tourists outside. With the advent of the Qinghai-Lhasa train line, Chinese tourists have flooded into the Land of Snows to experience the most authentic of eco- and ethno-tourism adventures. The allure of seeing ‘real’ Buddhist monks, of trekking through alpine meadows, and of snapping endless self-photos on Everest Base Camp is just too much for the adventurous Chinese tourist. Donning their matching, fluorescent baseball caps, they have come by the thousands on a sort of environmental and ethnological pilgrimage.

alt

Chinese tourists dress in traditional Tibetan wear outside the Potala Palace.

No one welcomes these so-called ‘Chinese pilgrims’ more than the local tourist agencies. With activities and trips designed especially for the Chinese tourist, these agencies have realized enormous profits over the past several years. These profits, however, are relished at the expense of the local environment and indigenous culture. Yes, while many tour operators boast themselves as eco- and ethno-friendly, most are far from such. It appears to me that such false claims are not mere misinterpretations of ecotourism standards, but instead strategic, marketing strategies. The strategy goes as follows: make Chinese client think that he is an ecotourist while actually allowing him to enjoy all of the amenities and luxuries that normally bring harm to the local ecosystem. Examples of such comforts include large hotels, luxury tour buses, massive restaurants, cigarette-smoking, loudspeakers, disrespectful camera use, littering, cement pathways in scenic areas, etc. Sure, incorporating these features into your tour will surely improve customer satisfaction. It will probably boost your profits too. But what about that silly thing called ecotourism?

The boom of the Tibetan tourism industry depends upon the allure of the local environment and indigenous culture. This allure, in turn, depends upon the commitment of local tour operators to eco- and ethno-tourism. Given as such, will local tour operators be forced to be true to their eco-friendly word? Or will the quest for profit result in the destruction of their only product? Ultimately, can China embrace ecotourism? More to come later…

4 Responses to “Monks and Snow Lions and Chinese Tourists…Oh My!”

  1. That the now famous “green is green” concept applies to China is no surprise. For anyone wakes up to days where the air is chock-full of pollution, feeling like they are doing their part may have some (marketing) value. And, well, we were going to go to Lhasa anyway, good for us, we did it “green” (and smoking).

    The real issue is that fake green is green. And non-green is green too. More importantly, the market has not provided enough green options nor are there mechanisms to authenticate green claims. In such an environment, how can we vote with our feet? After all, walking is green.
    .

  2. More like ego-tourism…Reminds me of car camping in the US– also not very eco– with National Parks sullied by asphalted cul-de-sacs, Porto potty stations, and $49 Boom Box cacophonies.

    As for embracing our indigenous culture– http://500nations.com

    In Tibet though, ego-tourism is being taken to a new level– 5,200 meters above sea level to be exact… at 40 km per hour — http://news.xinhuanet.com/english/2007-06/18/content_6259691.htm

    From green to non-green to gangrene.

  3. Hi there, simply was alert to your blog via Google, and found that it’s truly informative. I am gonna be careful for brussels. I’ll appreciate in the event you proceed this in future. A lot of other folks will be benefited out of your writing. Cheers!

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Managing The Dragon - Beta Version » Blog Archive » The Butter-Tea Blender - August 11, 2007

    [...] pictures of ancient monasteries and towering peaks, I try to relive the awe and excitement of my recent trip to Tibet. Even from my computer screen, the Potala Palace commands a sense of historical permanence, [...]